Is your HDB building wealth or draining it?

Understanding this now can mean the difference between a comfortable retirement and financial struggles, especially when comes the time when you retire.

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability Rober Kiyosaki

When Does Your HDB Start Becoming Your Liability?

Although your HDB may currently show an increase in value, as it ages, its appreciation slows or depreciates. Using HDB loans and CPF for payments can result in losing out on mortgage and CPF compounded interest.

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - Sell Point Chart

Consider a case study: Blk 645 Punggol Central's price trend and breakeven point after factoring in a 2.6% HDB loan and 2.5% CPF interest.

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - Sell Point Transaction

Let's say you purchased a 5 room HDB at Blk 645 Punggol Central at $370,000 in 2008. If you can turn back the time at which Sell Point will you sell your HDB or will you keep staying?

Most people will say Sell Point C because it's the highest transacted price. Well, let's break it down.

Purchase Price$370,000.00
10% Downpayment$37,000.00
Stamp Duty$5,700.00
Total Initial Capital Invested$42,700.00
Sell PointSell YearYrs HoldSell PriceGross ProceedPrinciple
paid
Loan InterestCPF InterestNett ProfitROE
A20125$592,000$222,000$39,145$40,843$4,951$170,505224%
B201912$432,000$62,000$104,328$85,140$29,973-$58,813-42%
C202417$700,000$330,000$157,913$110,500$62,706$151,09478%

Sell Point A

  • If you sell at this point. You might not get the highest selling price, but you paid the least loan and CPF Interest. Therefore your ROE is the highest among the 3 Sell Points.
    (Note: I did not use the highest selling price as a reference at Sell Point A because you cannot predict when it will be the peak. Nevertheless, the focus was on interest paid.)

Sell Point B

  • Assuming you sold at a bad time and made a loss with -42% ROE. This example shows that HDB prices do not always follow an upward trend. We are currently still on the upward trend since COVID-19 due to the supply crunch. However, how well will your HDB price hold when HDB is bumping up supplies and as your flat ages?

Sell Point C

  • The market turned around since Covid-19 and you got a lucky break and sold at the record price after hold 17 years. But as your loan interest and CPF compounded interest built up, your ROE is lower than if you sell at Sell Point A. We have a lucky break, but even with inflation in place, the cost of land and construction helping with pushing up property prices. We cannot deny the fact that HDB is still a leasehold property. Their value will depreciate due to lease decay.
  • Well, the good news you are also building capital as the CPF interest paid can be used for your next purchase. However, if you compare it to Sell Point A, you can purchase a newer property which might give you better growth, have a longer loan tenure which you have in lower installments, and make your money work harder for you.

Calculate Your HDB's Breakeven Point – Do the Math

To truly understand the financial impact of your HDB, you need to calculate its estimated breakeven price. Factor in mortgage payments, CPF interest, and the costs of homeownership. The reality? Your property must increase in value by 2.1% each year just to keep up. Can your HDB meet that expectation?

Let’s crunch the numbers together. Use our quick formula: [Purchase Price] + 45% (20 years x 2.1% annual increase + 3% stamp duty) = Breakeven Price.

If you’re unsure whether your HDB is growing in value or losing it, it’s time for a Property Health Check.


Don’t let your HDB become your biggest liability. With the right strategy, you can turn it into a powerful tool for building wealth. Here’s how with our 3 Steps Asset Progression Framework:

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - 3 steps asset progression framework

Real Success Stories

Mr. Lim engaged us for a property consultation session in 2016. They saw their property value decrease year by year since the 2013 peak. They were worried if they could recover their capital for their flat at Blk 167B Punggol East, after going through their Property Health Check and working out their finances. I advised them to switch to a property that has more growth potential as their flat was at risk of having negative sales.

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - swapping OTP

We made a switch from HDB to an
Executive Condominium (EC)

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - Swapping valuation

Today their EC is looking at more than $1 Million in Gross Profit

Mr. Lim is now ready to go into Step 3 of the Asset Progression Framework which is expanding his Property Portfolio and securing a financially free retirement.


What happens if he decides to stay on in his HDB?

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - case study chart
HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - case study transaction

If Mr. Lim decided to stay on and only sell in 2024 at $660,000 he could have made $240,000 more. But compared to what he did in 2016, that is, selling his HDB and switching to an EC he would have made $760K less. Of course, he could still switch in 2024 however his next home options will be lesser due to lower capital and shorter loan tenure due to age hence resulting in higher loan instalments.

Which option will you choose?


Get Your Property Health Check Now

(Just 1 hour of your time can change your financial future!)


Why Work with Me?

Steven Chia awards
Steven Chia Top 20 percent
What My Clients Say

How Much Do You Need For Retirement?

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - inflation rice

Have you felt the inflation?

When Economic Rice is not so economic. Recently I got a plate of economic rice with one vegetable dish, one toufu, and one meat and it cost me $6.30 at a food court in one of our General Hospitals.

I couldn't help but think how much would I need for retirement 20 years later.

So I asked ChatGPT and this is what I got.

If you retire 20 years later in 2044, it is estimated that each person will need $2,235 per month for basic needs.

And if you live till 85 years old, you will need $2,235 x 12 months = $26,820 x 20 years = $536,400 per person.

That is provided you have a good medical insurance plan, no lavish lifestyle, and no pampering yourself with good food and good holidays, or even just giving your grandkids some occasion treats.

Nevertheless, you decide the lifestyle you want during retirement. But for me, having more is always better.

HDB an Asset or a Hidden Liability - old man working

Make working after retirement a choice and not because you have to.


Why you should register for a Property Health Check

  • Estimate the valuation of your property (Without visual assessment)
  • Nearby Amenities - Understand the selling point of your location
  • Block Price Trend - How your block price trend performed
  • Street Similar Property Trend - Know how much the buyer is willing to pay for the properties along the same street
  • 500M Similar Property Trend - Know how much your neighbour within a 500m radius sold their price and you are able to fetch the same price or higher
  • Recent Transaction - Understand how much buyers are willing to pay for different level
  • Free 1 hr consultation for property visual assessment and market asking analytics for Pricing Strategy you can adopt